The Scarlett Letter Argumentative Essay
In the Scarlett Letter simply by Hawthorn, open public humiliation is used as a type of punishment. Because place and time period, the seventeenth century, Puritanical Boston, Massachusettes, this form of treatment was fairly common. There was zero separation of church and state during that time and since Puritan beliefs were based on good versus evil, it was a common practice to humiliate, chastise, and berate people as a scare approach to keep order. Fast toward the 20 or so First 100 years. We clearly have seperation of church and state. People are prohibited to be discriminated against by any means, shape or form. We now have constitutional legal rights that allow for freedom of speech. Our culture, in this region, is 1 based on the shape of government find out as Democracy. Yet, individuals have taken it upon themselves to publically humiliate a relative or a family member to teach them a lesson and reprimand that loved one. Is this acceptable for our modern society? So what do you think? Even though it is being employed today, there are other punative methods that are much more successful.
Cases of community humiliation today are showing up via the new multimedia. In an article posted simply by Fox Reports on April 21, 2012, it was explained that a assess ordered a man that got killed one more man because he was driving under the influence of alcoholic beverages, to wear an indication admitting that he killed the man intended for four Saturdays in a line from being unfaithful: 00 A. M. To 5: 00 L. M., while at the crash site, as part of his phrase. The same evaluate also ordered that the convicted man hold a picture with the crash in the living space. (MyFoxaustin. com) While revisiting the criminal offenses scene and having the regular reminder of what this kind of man, Giacona, did via the picture dangling in his living room likely had a significant impact on Giacona, whether having been wearing a indication while visiting the site, much more than likey, had not been the most significant area of the punishment. Staying shamed when being before one's colleagues is quite embarassing at the time it really is happening, although is quite rapidly forgotten following it is above.
Within recent document, a man that had constantly speed raced through a shopping area in Florida was performed to wear an indicator saying, " Dont' streets race” pertaining to fifty progressive, gradual Sundays kind 1: 00 A. Meters. To 2: 00 A. M. near the shopping Center that he raced. How many people basically saw this kind of man only at that late time was not mentioned in the article. The twenty four year old, Regato, himself possibly stated " no Problem” when asked to do it. He was thankful for this punshment rather than getting quickly sent back to jail. " It's mare like a public humiliation than a community service, " said Kimberly Lavender, a spokeswoman pertaining to the American Civil Liberties Union, Sarasota, in Ohio. "... More than likely it provide the community better if your husband was undertaking community support in a hospital? " (Associated Press, March 2 2005) The community services would have basically accomplished something towards running along quite well for others in that community. Producing a real big difference to someone else is all section of the paying back aiming to make up for the wrong work that people produce. Community service is a great sort of how retribution is more effective sort of punishment than is community humiliation.
One may still admit public embarrassment is worth an attempt in today's contemporary society with all of the cultural problems, large crime rates, and so forth etc .. At a minimum a person may be able to correspond with the all judges, in cases described here, applying these non-traditional and traditional ways to try to keep people from repating these types of criminal offenses because nothing else seems to quit some people's behaviors. However though, is it really producing a difference permanent? Is there any real evidence or exploration to support that using this type of public humiliation is usually reducing the quantity of these types of criminal activity? The answer is no . Individuals who have similar actions with their liked...
Cited: NG, Christina, HURUF. com weblog, 12, Jan. 2012
Thompson, Paul, MyFoxdc. com. 28, Aug., 2009
Associated Press, MyFoxaustin. com, 2 Mar, 2005